Appstle | How to Measure the Success of Shopify Customer Loyalty Program

How to Measure the Success of Shopify Customer Loyalty Program

Appstle | How to Measure the Success of Shopify Customer Loyalty Program

Spread the Word

Table of Contents

How to Measure the Success of Shopify Customer Loyalty Program

Customer loyalty programs have become a must-have for businesses to boost customer retention. Offering rewards and exclusive benefits to loyal customers help improve brand advocacy and increase sales.

But, not all e-commerce businesses see success with loyalty programs due to various factors such as poor implementation, lack of relevance to customer needs, and poor customer experience. These factors can discourage customers from participating in the loyalty program, leading to its failure.

Customer loyalty metrics are crucial in determining the success of a loyalty program. Measuring the performance of your loyalty program through metrics is crucial in identifying and addressing any problems that you may be facing in customer retention.  

Customer loyalty analysis provides valuable insights into the program’s performance, allowing businesses to identify areas for improvement and make data-driven decisions.

So, here are the metrics you need to measure the success of your customer loyalty program. 

Customer loyalty program metrics you should measure  

While the customer loyalty program metrics you measure may vary based on the goal and objective of your strategy, here are some we recommend to our customers

1. Customer Loyalty Programme Enrolment Rate

Measuring the customer loyalty program enrolment rate is crucial because it helps businesses understand how effectively they are promoting their loyalty program to customers.

The formula to measure customer loyalty program Enrolment Rate-

Enrolment Rate = (Number of loyalty program members / Total number of customers) x 100

A high enrolment rate indicates that customers are interested in the loyalty program, which can lead to increased customer retention and revenue.

By tracking the enrolment rate, businesses can evaluate the success of their marketing efforts and identify areas for improvement. 

2. Participation Rate

A high participation rate indicates that customers are actively engaging with the program and using its benefits, which can lead to increased customer retention and revenue. 

The formula to measure customer loyalty Participation Rate.

Participation Rate = (Number of customers who participated in the loyalty program / Total number of eligible customers) x 100

A low participation rate can indicate that the rewards or benefits offered by the program may not be valuable or relevant to customers, providing valuable insights to businesses in terms of optimizing the program.

By tracking the participation rate, businesses can also identify any barriers that may be preventing customers from engaging with the program and make necessary improvements to increase participation. 

3. Customer Loyalty Programme Repeat Purchase Rate

A high repeat purchase rate indicates that customers are loyal and are consistently making purchases with the business, which can lead to increased revenue and profitability.

Measure customer loyalty with the formula:

Repeat Purchase Rate = (Number of repeat purchases within a given period / Total number of customers) x 100

To measure customer loyalty metrics, tracking the repeat purchase rate is essential as businesses can evaluate the success of their loyalty program and identify areas for improvement.

4. Average Spend Per Member

By tracking the average spend per member, businesses can evaluate how much customers are spending as a result of the loyalty program’s benefits and rewards. 

Measure customer loyalty with the formula:

Total revenue generated from loyalty program / Number of loyalty program members

A high average spend per member indicates that the program is effectively driving customer engagement and loyalty, leading to increased revenue and profitability. 

Additionally, businesses can use this metric to identify high-value customers and tailor their loyalty program benefits to incentivize these customers to spend even more.

5. Lifetime Value of the Loyalty Programme 

By tracking the lifetime value of loyalty program members, businesses can evaluate how much revenue each member generates throughout their relationship with the business.

Lifetime Value (LTV) = (Average Purchase Value * Number of Purchases per Year * Average Retention Time in Years) – Cost of Acquisition

A high lifetime value indicates that the loyalty program is effectively driving customer retention and repeat business, leading to increased revenue and profitability over time. 

6. Percentage of Sales From Customer Loyalty Members

Measuring the percentage of sales from customer loyalty members is important because it helps businesses understand the impact of their loyalty program on overall revenue. 

Percentage of Sales from Customer Loyalty Members =

(Total Sales from Loyalty Program Members / Total Sales) x 100

By tracking this metric, businesses can evaluate how much revenue is generated specifically from loyal customers who are members of the loyalty program. 

A high percentage of sales from loyalty members indicates that the program is effectively driving customer retention and repeat business, leading to increased revenue and profitability.

7. Customer Retention Rate 

The customer retention rate measures the percentage of customers who continue to do business with a company over a given period. 

Measure customer loyalty with the formula:

CRR = ((E-N)/S)) x 100

Where:

  • E is the number of customers at the end of a period
  • N is the number of new customers acquired during that period
  • S is the number of customers at the start of that period

By tracking this metric, businesses can evaluate how many customers are returning to make additional purchases, which is a key factor in driving long-term revenue growth. 

A high customer retention rate indicates that the loyalty program is effectively incentivizing customers to remain engaged with the business and make repeat purchases.

8. Incremental Margin From Customers

Incremental margin is the additional profit generated by loyal customers as a result of their participation in the loyalty program. 

The formula to measure customer loyalty Incremental Margin from Customers:

Incremental Margin from Customers = (Revenue from Loyalty Members – Cost of Goods Sold) / Number of Loyalty Members

By tracking this metric, businesses can evaluate how much profit is being generated by loyal customers and the overall impact of the loyalty program on profitability.

A high incremental margin indicates that the loyalty program is effectively incentivizing customers to make additional purchases and generating additional revenue for the business. 

9. Organic Return Rates for Members

This metric measures the percentage of customers who return to make purchases without the influence of any loyalty program rewards or promotions. 

By tracking this metric, businesses can evaluate how well they are building lasting customer relationships through their loyalty program. A high organic return rate indicates that customers are loyal to the business and continue to make purchases even without being incentivized by the loyalty program. 

This can be a strong indicator of customer satisfaction, and can also help businesses identify their most loyal customers and measure customer loyalty.

10. Reduction in Discount Cost

This metric measures the decrease in discount costs that result from loyal customers making purchases through the loyalty program. 

Measure customer loyalty with the formula:

Reduction in Discount Cost = Total discount cost before loyalty program – Total discount cost after loyalty program

By tracking this metric, businesses can evaluate the effectiveness of their loyalty program in driving customer loyalty and increasing profitability. A high reduction in discount cost indicates that the loyalty program is successful in incentivizing customers to make purchases, without requiring excessive discounts or promotions. 

This can help businesses improve their profitability, as loyal customers are often more likely to make repeat purchases and require less marketing and advertising spending to drive sales.

11. Advocacy or Referral Rates

This metric measures the percentage of customers who refer new customers to the business through word-of-mouth or other means. 

Measure customer loyalty with the formula:

Referral Rate = (Number of referrals / Total number of customers) x 100%

By tracking this metric, businesses can evaluate how well their loyalty program is driving customer loyalty and advocacy, and identify opportunities to improve the program to further increase referral rates. 

A high referral rate indicates that customers are highly satisfied with the business and its products or services, and are willing to share their positive experiences with others.

12. Net Promoter Score (NPS)

NPS is a metric that measures the likelihood of a customer recommending a business’s products or services to others on a scale of 0-10. By calculating the percentage of promoters (customers who give a score of 9 or 10) and detractors (customers who give a score of 0-6), businesses can determine their overall NPS.

Measure customer loyalty with the formula:

NPS = % of Promoters (customers who gave a score of 9 or 10) – % of Detractors (customers who gave a score of 0 to 6)

A high NPS indicates that customers are highly satisfied with the business and are likely to recommend it to others, which can be a powerful driver of new customer acquisition and revenue growth. On the other hand, a low NPS indicates that customers are dissatisfied with the business, which can lead to negative word-of-mouth and customer churn.

By tracking NPS over time, businesses can evaluate the effectiveness of their loyalty program in driving customer satisfaction and loyalty.

13. Upsell Ratio

The upsell ratio is the percentage of customers who upgrade to a higher-priced product or service after being presented with an offer.

Measure customer loyalty with the formula:

Upsell Ratio = Total Revenue from Upsells / Total Revenue from Sales

By measuring the upsell ratio, businesses can determine how successful their loyalty program is in encouraging customers to spend more and purchase higher-value products or services. A high upsell ratio indicates that customers are engaged and interested in the business’s offerings, which can lead to increased revenue and profitability.

Furthermore, businesses can use the data from the upsell ratio to optimize their loyalty program and improve the effectiveness of their upsell offers.

14. Customer Loyalty Index (CLI)

The CLI is calculated based on factors such as customer satisfaction, likelihood to repurchase, and likelihood to recommend the business to others. 

Customer Loyalty Index Formula = [(Number of Repeat Customers)/(Total Number of Customers)] x 100

By measuring the CLI, businesses can identify areas where they may be falling short in terms of customer loyalty, and take steps to improve customer satisfaction and loyalty. 

This could include improving the quality of products or services, enhancing the customer experience, or offering more personalized rewards and incentives through their loyalty program.

15. Redemption Rate

The redemption rate is an important metric to measure for any loyalty program. This metric tells you how many members are redeeming the rewards they have earned through the loyalty program.

Measure customer loyalty with the formula:

Redemption Rate = Total Points Redeemed / Total Points Issued x 100

A high redemption rate indicates that members find the rewards valuable and are motivated to use them, which in turn can lead to increased customer loyalty and repeat purchases. On the other hand, a low redemption rate may indicate that members are not finding the rewards appealing or that the redemption process is too complicated.

Measuring the redemption rate can also help businesses identify which rewards are most popular among customers and which ones are not performing well.

16. Point issuance ratio

The point issuance ratio is an important metric to measure for any loyalty program. This metric tells you how many points are being issued to customers for their purchases or actions, compared to the overall sales or activities in the program.

Measure customer loyalty with the formula:

Point Issuance Ratio = Total Points Issued / Total Sales

By tracking the point issuance ratio, businesses can ensure that their loyalty program is effectively incentivizing customers to make purchases or engage with the brand in other ways. 

If the ratio is too low, it may indicate that the rewards offered are not motivating enough, and adjustments may be needed to increase engagement and participation in the program.

17. Stock in-kind rewards

Measuring the stock of in-kind rewards is important to ensure that a loyalty program does not run out of rewards to offer to its members. 

If the program runs out of rewards, members may become dissatisfied and feel that their loyalty is not being adequately rewarded. On the other hand, if the program has excess rewards, it could lead to unnecessary costs for the business.

18. Active Engagement Rate

An active engagement rate can indicate whether the loyalty program is successful in driving customer engagement, increasing brand loyalty, and generating revenue. 

Measure customer loyalty with the formula:

Active Engagement Rate = (Number of Active Loyalty Members / Total Number of Loyalty Members) x 100

A high active engagement rate suggests that customers are loyal to the brand and are actively participating in the program, which can lead to increased sales and revenue. 

On the other hand, a low active engagement rate may indicate that the loyalty program is not effectively engaging customers and may require adjustments to improve its effectiveness.

Conclusion 

A good loyalty program typically includes an analytics dashboard that allows businesses to easily measure and track various metrics related to the program’s performance.

An analytics dashboard also helps businesses to segment their customers and personalize their loyalty program to better suit each customer’s preferences and behaviors.

Appstle provides end-to-end membership functionality with a detailed analytical dashboard allowing for easy setup of tiered plans to enhance reach and loyalty, increased conversion with targeted perks and analytics.

Get in touch today!

About the author

Appstle | How to Measure the Success of Shopify Customer Loyalty Program

Vanhishikha Bhargava

Vanhishikha Bhargava is the Content Marketer for Appstle Solutions. You’ll always find her creating content or reading up on the industry with a cup of coffee in hand, which makes her anxious at times! But stay tuned for insightful pieces. Always.

If you are looking to understand more about Appstle Inc’s products and solutions, you can get in touch with us. Our 24x7x365 available experts will be happy to assist you further.

Related Posts

As Seen On

“A strong e-commerce presence is more of a necessity today, and Appstle has made it possible by offering sound solutions and functionalities.” 

– USA Today

Reviews
5/5

Trusted by over
25,000
Shopify Plus and Shopify brands

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top

Get In Touch!